Skip to main content

Greece: money and support only for the banks

The Greek banks have been bailed out with billions exceeding 90% of country's GDP since 2008. When citizens suffer from heavy taxes, unemployment strikes the Greek society, Greek economy faces deep recession and Greeks sink in poverty, it appears that Greek governments do have money, but only for the banks. Billions were given in bailouts, but no one knows where the money went and how they were exploited. The only thing that is certain is that they didn't go where they should go: to the real economy.

by Vangelis Triantis

In October 2008, the situation in Greek economy was far away from today's picture. The Greek economy was growing and the first signs of the global financial crisis appeared shyly. The then minister of finance, George Alogoskoufis, announced a bailout package of 28 billion euros for the banks in order to face competitiveness problems, in other words, to face liquidity problems and secure the deposits. Next to him was sitting the governor of the Bank of Greece, George Provopoulos, whose role was crucial for the formation of today's Greek banking map and is responsible for a series of banking scandals which came out to publicity.

Only 11 billion from this bailout package were used by the Greek banks, but this was just for a start. In 2010, Papandreou administration approved the rest 17 billion through the 3845/2010 law. Little later, another 25 billion euros approved through the 3072 law, from which 21.8 billion were used. The banking sector was continuously asking for support. In private conversations with government officials, top bankers were claiming that they should be supported, otherwise the banking system would collapse and the Greek economy would suffer serious damage. In 2011, Papandreou administration approved another 30 billion, through the 3965 law, under some requirements this time. The total amount reached at 49.8 billion since 2008. This was only the one side of the bank bailouts.

The crisis which eventually hit the Greek banking system, continuous downgrades of the Greek economy from rating agencies and the exclusion from markets, were facts which changed the then status. For years, banks were addicted to easy money, borrowing cheaply from ECB and lending at quite high interests in Greece. Through this way they were making huge profits. However, things have changed in 2009 as crisis hit the Greek economy for good. Thousands depositors were sending money abroad and Greek banks were running out of deposits. The banking sector collapse was very close, or at least, this view was promoted by the bankers.

BoG and ELA

In order to stimulate liquidity for the banking system, Bank of Greece (BoG) started a program under the name Emergency Liquidity Assistance (ELA), in order to provide liquidity for the banks. Specifically, banks were giving guarantees of the Greek Public to receive liquidity which was less than the guarantees' nominal value because both ECB and ELA were not giving then, neither now, the whole guarantee amount. From then, BoG was able to provide liquidity for the banks, initially with 15 billion. Subsequently, were given another 30 billion, therefore 45 billion in total. Another 30 billion were given through the 4031/11 law and 30 billion through the 4056/11 law, elevating the total amount at 105 billion euros.

More simply, the total amount of Greek state guarantees given to the Greek banks since 2008 to date, reached at 154.8 billion euros. This is a huge amount for the Greek banking system, but it's not the only one because banks were greedy. Under the PSI program, the banks received another 50 billion, from the 130 billion of the second bailout package for Greece, in order to be recapitalised. This amount together with the 154.8 billion, elevated the total amount of state loans and guarantees at 204.8 billion euros, which is more than 90% of Greece's GDP.

Where did the money go?

The question now is: where did the money go? More than five years since the beginning of the global financial storm, the banks received billions in bailouts in the form of loans and guarantees, without any positive impact on the real economy. The banking system still facing big problems and bank loans are very rare. The market is more frozen than ever and the bailouts were not effective for the recovery of the real economy. No one knows the way that all these billions were exploited and no one gives an answer.

Kiriakos Tompras, president of the movement "Hipervasi" said to HotDoc: "They [the banks] took 310 billion in total, to secure their capital adequacy, liquidity and cover of deposits. However, even today they are unable to guarantee deposits and we are asking, where did the money go", and "... the BoG and Ministry of Finance should explain to us where did the money go because if we had a money flow to the real economy, then we should have growth".

The truth is that the banks used the money they received from the Financial Stability Fund (FSF) to reduce their exposure to ECB and ELA, instead of financing the real economy. At this moment, banks' exposure to ECB and ELA has reduced at 75 billion, without, however, the complete withdrawal of Greek state guarantees, while at the same time, ECB is pressing for further reduction of the Greek banking system's exposure. The banks however, state that they still hold EFSF (European FSF) bonds which they can use if necessary. Therefore, Greek state guarantees are, essentially, still active.

"Holes", mishandling and frauds

A serious matter which needs clear answer is whether all that money were used by the bankers to cover their banks' holes, i.e. losses from bad directing and bad managing. During stress tests for the Greek banks, for example, the foreign portfolios were not examined at all, where there seem to be offshore companies which they belonged either to bankers or to other people close to them. Investigations from the HotDoc, Reuters and NY Times have bring to publicity many cases which smell scandal.

A characteristic example is Piraeus bank. Some other companies of the bank CEO Michalis Sallas, were receiving loans from the Marfin-Popular bank which they were used to raise Piraeus' stock capital. Specifically, according to the answer of the Central Bank of Cyprus to Irini Charalampidou, MP with the Cypriot party AKEL, this case concerns three companies based in Cyprus: KAEO Enterprises, Shent Enterprises and Benidver Investments. KAEO Enterprises belongs personally to Sallas, while the other two have recently transferred to his two children.

These companies received loans from the then Marfin Egnatia bank in order to participate in the increase of the stock capital of Piraeus bank. They owe, even today, 112.5 million euros in total. Guarantees were also given for these loans: a 7.2 million letter of guarantee from Piraeus bank and a 66.2 million collateral of stocks of Piraeus bank. However, the stockholders of these companies, i.e. Sallas family, never provided any personal guarantees, while little later, the Central Bank of Cyprus demanded a process for predictions concerning a total amount of 87.8 million euros.

Proton Bank, ATE and Marfin-Popular

The presence of Marfin-Popular bank in Cyprus is another case with the smell of scandal besides that of Piraeus bank. According to various statements to the Institutions and Transparency Commission of the Cypriot Parliament, the bank was used for loaning entrepreneurs and businesses which were serving Andreas Vgenopoulos* interests, with terms incompatible to the banking system rules. The money were used for the increase of the stock capital of MIG, among other things.

Another case is that of Proton bank and the entrepreneur Lavrentis Lavrentiadis, who seems that he used the bank in order to fund companies of his interests. Through this way, he managed to provide a false picture of healthy business activities, which was very far from reality, something which was revealed soon through the Proton bank scandal. There are also lots of questions about the stance of the BoG's governor, George Provopoulos, concerning the gaining of control of Proton bank by Lavrentiadis. As the HotDoc revealed, despite the negative propositions from other BoG executives, Mr. Provopoulos approved, eventually, the gaining of control of Proton bank by Lavrentiadis. The subsequent events, are more or less known. The bank collapsed and Lavrentiadis was put in jail, while the Greek people had to pay the cost for Proton bailout through a law from Evangelos Venizelos.

The case of the Agricultural Bank of Greece (ATE), was another big scandal. A [public] bank was deliberately downgraded in order to be sold at a ridiculous price to Piraeus bank.** With exception of the loans to the political parties, no one bothered to check the red loans of the bank: where did they go and under what terms?

An attempt to cover up?

Where did all the money go? No one bothered to check, despite the accusations and publication of scandals. On the contrary, ECB hired Oliver Wyman***, a US-based financial consultancy, which has repeatedly helped banks and governments to cover up the fact that various banks of eurozone were bankrupted, as for example last year in Spain and six years ago in Ireland.

Whether will continue to do this job in other eurozone countries, among them Greece, is something that no one can tell with certainty. What is certain is that in Greece, the banking system received bailouts equal to 90% of country's GDP, while the real economy is sinking without receiving any loans to stay alive.


Article from the HotDoc printed edition, Issue 40, Nov. 2013
(Translated by SCH)


** It is worth to remember the scandal of "selling" the healthy part of public bank Agrotiki to Piraeus Bank in July 2012. The governor of the Bank of Greece, George Provopoulos, had stated that it was a necessary action because the European Central Bank was about to cut the necessary amount of 6,3 billion euros and Agrotiki would have closed, so, many people would have lost their jobs. However, according to the bill concerning this "selling", the difference between assets and liabilities of Agrotiki Bank, was nearly 6,67 billion euros and should be covered exclusively by the Greek Financial Stability Fund, ie the Greek taxpayers! Which means that the "selling" was targeting only to assist a private bank (Piraeus) to eliminate a competitor (public bank Agrotiki), and secure its position in the "Too Big to Fail" category.

On 27 July of 2012 the big scandal of “selling” the healthy part of the public bank Agrotiki to the private bank Piraeus is finalized. Just three days before, on 24 July of 2012, Panagiotis Roumeliotis - ex-representative of Greece in IMF and currently vice chairman at Piraeus bank – in a statement to NY Times supports that: “We knew at the fund from the very beginning that this program was impossible to be implemented because we didn’t have any successful example...”. The statement was spread rapidly from the Greek media. With this “honest confession”, Roumeliotis says something that nearly everyone knows: that the IMF policies have been followed dogmatically since they have been unsuccessful everywhere they applied. The bankers are playing the card of IMF, knowing that nearly noone believes in its good intensions anyway, in an attempt to distract the pubic attention from the big scandal which is about to come three days later. However, it seems that during the next days this tactic was about to fail, since a significant part of the opposition in the Greek parliament as well as several indepentent Greek blogs and websites were speaking clearly about a big scandal refering to the “selling” of Agrotiki bank to Piraeus bank, while they were revealing all the details of this action, something which the mainstream media rushed to hide through a simple announcement. Next, as more and more people were focusing on the real scandal, Roumeliotis was called to testify to the authorities in order for his statement to gain officialy the appropriate importance, in a new attempt to distract the public attention. The official state was fully co-ordinated with the banking establishment to distract the public attention, while normally, the state authorities should have call the architects of the real scandal to give explanations about the fact that the healthy part of a public bank was given to a private bank with the money of the taxpayers and the “garbage” remains were loaded to them.

Comments

  1. This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Hello ,
    Am Mrs Cynthia corvin . Am a lady with a great testimony I live in USA and i am a happy woman today? and i told my self that any lender that rescue my family from our poor situation, i will refer any person that is looking for loan to him, he gave happiness to me and my family, i was in need of a loan of $360,000.00 to start my life all over as i am a mother with 2 kids I met this honest and GOD fearing man loan lender that help me with a loan of $360,000.0.Dollar, he is a GOD fearing man, if you are in need of loan and you will pay back the loan please contact him tell him that is Mrs cynthia corvin, that refer you to him. contact Mr.Zak,via email:- feroozsuptoo@outlook.com

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Why are Israeli war criminals hiding out in Patagonia?

The Grayzone   The Grayzone 's Oscar Leon examines reports of Israeli veterans of Gaza hiding out in the Patagonia region of Argentina, a country governed by a hardcore supporter of Israel who has forged close ties to messianic networks and the government of Benjamin Netanyahu. To place the issue in a wider context, Leon spoke to veteran Argentine journalist Sebastian Salgado, and Santiago Cuneo, a former boss of Milei and now one of his fiercest opponents. 

BRICS expands to majority of world population: Vietnam joins, USA fails to divide China & Vietnam

Geopolitical Economy Report   BRICS has expanded to 20 countries - 10 members and 10 partners - after adding Vietnam. BRICS+ now makes up 43.93% of world GDP (PPP) and 55.61% of the global population. Ben Norton explains how the US failed to divide China and Vietnam in the Second Cold War. 

Trump Welcomed a War Criminal to the White House

Senator Bernie Sanders   Benjamin Netanyahu has been indicted as a war criminal. His government is systematically killing and starving the people of Gaza. He will be remembered as one of the monsters of modern history. And Trump welcomed him to the White House.  

Funcionario de Trump: el director de la CIA “toma dictado” del Mossad sobre Irán

Un funcionario de la administración Trump le cuenta a The Grayzone que el Mossad israelí está usando al director de la CIA, John Ratcliffe y al jefe del CENTCOM, general Michael Kurilla, para influenciar a Trump con inteligencia manipulada sobre el programa nuclear iraní. Dentro de la Casa Blanca, los disidentes han sido aislados, preparando el terrenno para una guerra de cambio de régimen que pudiera costar vidas estadounidenses.   Max Blumenthal and Anya Parampil  Parte 4 - La jefa de gabinete aísla a Trump con “el general favorito de Israel”   El funcionario de la administración le contó a The Grayzone que la jefa de gabinete de la Casa Blanca, Suzie Wiles, se aseguró de que el presidente permaneciera rodeado por Ratcliffe y el general Michael Kurilla en los briefings relacionados con Irán. Se dice que Ratcliffe toma dictado del Mossad y lee los documentos que ellos prepararon al presidente sin ningún sentido de desapego crítico, o revelar que las valoraciones provinie...

As Trump threatens BRICS, it grows stronger, resisting US dollar and Western imperialism

Geopolitical Economy Report   US President Donald Trump has threatened heavy tariffs on BRICS, claiming the organization is "dead", but it is actually growing in size and influence. 10 members and 10 partners participated in the 2025 BRICS summit in Brazil, where they discussed plans for dedollarization, trade and investment in national currencies, and how to create a more multipolar global order. Ben Norton explains.     Related:   Trump's tariffs: A unique opportunity for BRICS and the Global South to fully escape from dollar tyranny

SHOCKING Outburst in EU Parliament: ‘Isráel Must Be Held Accountable!

The Africa News Network  

Israel is responsible for one of the cruelest genocides in modern history

UN Palestinian Rights Committee   In her address to the Human Rights Council on 3 July 2025, Francesca Albanese, the UN Special Rapporteur on the situation of human rights in the Palestinian territories occupied since 1967, warned of a genocide unfolding in Gaza and the West Bank.    She described the situation as “apocalyptic,” stating that “Israel is responsible for one of the cruelest genocides in modern history.”    With over 200,000 Palestinians reported killed or injured and the real toll “far higher,” she accused Israel of dismantling humanitarian aid in Gaza, replacing it with a “so-called 'Gaza Humanitarian Foundation' [that] is nothing else than a death trap.”    She emphasized that this was not an isolated crisis but part of a decades-long “settler colonial project of erasure” that has intensified in recent months through military force, starvation, and mass displacement. Albanese condemned the deep complicity of corporate and state actors i...

Israel Is Building A CONCENTRATION CAMP In Gaza

Owen Jones                    There are no pretenses here. No pretenses at all. This is a genocide being committed in front of the whole world.  

Trump’s Tariff Threat on BRICS BACKFIRES— Is He Fueling the Rebellion?

GVS Deep Dive   Donald Trump just slapped a 10% tariff threat on BRICS countries — calling them “anti-American” and accusing them of trying to destroy the U.S. dollar. But instead of weakening the bloc, his aggressive posture might be doing the opposite.   GVS Deep Dive unpacks Trump’s July 2025 tariff ultimatum, the explosive Truth Social posts, and the BRICS summit response from leaders like Lula and Modi. From new financial systems like BRICS Pay to de-dollarization and sovereign trade in local currencies, the Global South is pushing back. And here’s the twist: as Trump tries to defend the dollar with threats, he may actually be accelerating the very rebellion he fears. 🎯 Why is the U.S. struggling to sign new trade deals? 🇮🇳 Will India bend under Trump’s pressure — or break away? 🌍 Is BRICS the future of global power? 📉 And what happens if the dollar really does decline?     Related:  Trump's tariffs: A unique opportunity for BRICS and the Global So...

Spying on Iran: How MI6 infiltrated the IAEA

Leaked confidential files indicate the International Atomic Energy Agency was infiltrated by a veteran British spy who has claimed credit for sanctions on Iran. The documents lend weight to the Islamic Republic’s accusation that the nuclear watchdog secretly colluded with its enemies. by Kit Klarenberg Part 2 - Langman’s name placed under official UK censorship order In 2016, Langman was named a Companion of the Order of St Michael and St George, the same title bestowed on fictional British spy James Bond. By that point, the supposed secret agent held the dubious distinction of being publicly ‘burned’ as an MI6 operative on two separate occasions. First, in 2001, journalist Stephen Dorril revealed that Langman had arrived in Paris weeks prior to Princess Diana’s fatal car crash in the city on August 31 1997, and was subsequently charged with conducting “information operations” to deflect widespread public speculation British intelligence was responsible for her death. Then, in 2005, he...